Author: James Tiptree, Jr
Edition: 0-812-55625-9
Pages: 375
Synopsis: Brightness Falls From the Air plots one long night as the remnants of a great war play over a lonely planet. A group of tourists has gathered to take in the event, but the night takes on a new shape as danger makes itself known.
There is an interesting perspective for this novel. Instead of taking place during first contact, where one race does terrible damage to the other, this book starts off during the aftermath as humans are repairing relations with the dameii, a race of insectoid aliens whom they’ve injured gruesomely in the past. There is a bit of mystery since we don’t start the story knowing everything that’s happened; we figure out the history between the two peoples over the course of the telling, and of course that history becomes the focus of the novel as two plots erupt around a small party of tourists and their guides.
Tiptree’s writing is all her own; personally, I haven’t read anything truly comparable to her style. The tense and often her way of describing things are unusual, although Brightness Falls From the Air is not so much unusual as her short stories.
The road improves. Damiem’s yellow sun, called here Yrrei, is rising through a pink fleece of fine-weather cloudlets and igniting little rainbows in all the dewy foliage. The streamer-trees give way to flowering shrubs and light green bird-trees. Many of the mobile bird-leaves take off and flap curiously after the jitney. As usual, the tourist love this; even the dour Aquaman brightens as some leaves settle for a brief rest on the edge of the jitney near him.
This book, like Tiptree’s other writings, is very sentimental. Despite the strong plot full of mystery, the different threads of history that affect everything, the strongly built world, this novel is definitely about its characters. It’s impossible not to loathe some of them and dread the tragedies that befall others. Every character inspires some emotion.
Tiptree also has an interesting way of examining life and death.The author herself committed suicide after killing her husband (in her suicide note she basically explained it as a mercy killing), and struggled with depression and had previously attempted to take her life as well. Understandably, a lot of her writing is depressing and dark due to her own nature, but surprisingly Brightness Falls From the Air is actually a very uplifting, hopeful tale despite the darkness in it. Still, life and death are concepts that are examined here, as well as rebirth.
There are actually a lot of different themes in this book, including life and death. The characters, all from different planets, all have different cultures. There are the morally secure Federation types, soft-porn stars from the future version of Hollywood, an orphan who has traveled vastly, royalty and nobility from two different worlds, etc. It produces an interesting result as these characters interact with one another, and as they are all drawn together by what happens to them. This also discusses race relations between the cultures of the human and delicate dameii, as well as a now extinct race of aliens that had previously contended with humans.
(I know that some sci-fi & fantasy readers are looking for books that have GLBT characters or authors, and this book falls somewhat into that category. There is one gay couple among the main characters, although their relationship is more just a matter of fact and isn’t really examined. Tiptree herself was bisexual.)
The science serves as a backdrop for the novel rather than the focus, so this is really more of a fantasy. Given Tiptree’s background in the military, there is also a lot of military influence in the novel.
I’d recommend this novel to anyone who is after an interestingly written piece, or one who cares about any of the themes I’ve mentioned as they are all critical to the story.
Off the topic of the story, the more Tiptree I read the more I’m not impressed by the people who were so sure she was actually a male writer. To be honest, she does a lot of things that are more stereotypically female than male, from the way she writes her sex scenes to the sentimentality of her stories—she’s even more sentimental than Arthur C. Clarke. Given the time during which she wrote, a lot of her writing has a very obvious feminist edge to it. And unlike many of her contemporaries, women feature prominently as characters—not the beautiful, back-row type of male authors of this time, but the type who have jobs and careers, thoughts, and goals. They are just as realistic as male characters. And yes, she does have a few girls who are there only as candy, but she also has some unimportant male figures in her writing, as well. Honestly, if I’d read her works during the time when people were unsure whether she was male or female, I would have been unable to commit to either side of that fence.